By Julius Melnitzer | November 17, 2026
AI CAN’T PRACTISE LAW IN CALIFORNIA
California lawyers may no longer “delegate the practice of law” to generative AI. Governor Gavin Newsom signed Senate Bill 574 on September 30, after it passed the Assembly 75-0 and the Senate 40-0.
Lawyers must check every citation AI produces and advise the court whenever they use AI on a court document. Client confidences and personal identifying information can’t go into an AI system unless access is restricted to those bound to keep them confidential.
The law impacts arbitrators too. They can’t delegate any part of their decision-making to AI. Nor can they rely on AI-generated material from outside the record unless they tell the parties first. The law takes effect January 1, 2027.
MEDIATOR TO ONTARIO AG: WHY NOT START CIVIL REFORM WITH THE LOW-HANGING FRUIT?
Toronto mediator Barry Fisher, responding to my November 4 column on Ontario’s stalled civil justice reform, wants to know why Attorney General Doug Downey hasn’t at least expanded mandatory mediation beyond Toronto, Ottawa and Windsor-Essex.
Fisher understands that Downey considers mediation an extra expense. Since the parties pay the mediator, Fisher assumes the AG meant an extra expense for litigants, not the government. But mediation costs more only when the case doesn’t settle, Fisher says, and experienced mediators settle 80% to 90% of their cases.
Two judges in the U.K. have been disciplined for misconduct over delay, the Law Society Gazette reports. Trouble is, they likely didn’t notice the slap on the wrist — or was it a tap? Judge Lynn Griffin went for over a year without issuing judgment or dealing with post-hearing applications in a case before the General Regulatory Chamber. The parties had to start over before a different panel. Griffin, who had been sanctioned for delay once before, got off with a formal warning.
District Judge Allan Pickup took 12½ weeks to put an undertaking and an adjournment order in writing, leaving a self-represented litigant unable to enforce the undertaking. He was also a repeat offender, but again got away with “formal advice.”
COMPETENCE COMPLAINTS SOAR, REGULATOR SHRUGS
Public reports about solicitors’ competence in England and Wales rose from 2,720 in 2024 to 4,038 in 2025, the Law Society Gazette reports, but the Solicitors Regulation Authority says it’s satisfied that competence among solicitors isn’t declining. Competence complaints, the Gazette notes, held at 23% of all complaints, which also rose. That’s cold comfort to whoever filed those 4,038 reports.
In some cases, clients weren’t told enough about risks, likely outcomes, and their options. The SRA put that down to gaps in communication skills. That’s insightful. And in the no-surprise category, the SRA reported that some solicitors rarely take ethics training. So if the Legal Services Board approves, the SRA will require solicitors to have an annual three-hour ethics “discussion.” Someone should hold a contest to determine the best take on what those “discussions” will look like.
INDIA’S BAR TO FOREIGN LAWYERS: KEEP OUT
The Bar Council of India is looking for statutory amendments that would bar foreign lawyers and firms from appearing in Indian courts, practising Indian law or litigating. The only exception is arbitration, but only because, the BCI says, India is “lagging far behind” Singapore and Hong Kong. The implication: India’s courts, with their interminable delays, aren’t lagging behind anyone. The changes look like a retreat from 2025 regulations that would have let foreign lawyers and firms practise in India, albeit in limited circumstances, the Law Society Gazette reports. The BCI says it will do nothing that “could hamper/adversely affect the interests of our Indian law firms.” Nothing the Gazette quotes from the BCI mentions the public interest.
Julius Melnitzer is a Toronto-based legal affairs writer, ghostwriter, writing coach and media trainer. Readers can reach him at julius@legalwriter.net or on this website.